The Honest Review of Baby-Led Weaning After Trying It With Two Kids
When I first heard about baby-led weaning, I imagined a cheerful baby sitting at the family table, picking up colourful strips of food while everyone ate the same dinner. It sounded relaxed, economical and wonderfully free from spoon-feeding battles. Then I tried it with my first baby and discovered that the reality involved just as much floor cleaning as family bonding. Learn more about Sundayswithsophie.com.
With my second child, I approached the process with less pressure and a much clearer understanding of what suited our household. I had learned that baby-led weaning is not a test of parenting skill, and a mixed approach can work beautifully. Some days meant finger foods, some days involved a pre-loaded spoon, and some meals were simply too chaotic for anything ambitious.
This is my honest review after trying baby-led weaning with two children in an Australian family setting. It includes the wins, the mess, the safety concerns, the cost, and the parts I would handle differently next time.
What baby-led weaning looked like in our house
We began when each baby was showing the usual signs of readiness: sitting upright with steady head control, reaching for food and bringing objects to the mouth. In line with Australian guidance, we waited until around six months rather than using age alone as the deciding factor. Both babies could join us at the table and seemed genuinely interested in meals.
Our first meals were soft sticks of roasted sweet potato, steamed broccoli, ripe avocado, banana and toast fingers. I cut food into shapes that were easy for a small hand to grip, usually about the length of an adult finger. Later, we added shredded meat, omelette strips, pasta, rice and soft vegetables.
The phrase “baby-led” made me think I needed to avoid all spoon-feeding, but that became unnecessarily rigid. With both children, I offered a loaded spoon of yoghurt, porridge or mashed beans and let them guide it to their mouths. The important part was allowing them to participate rather than trying to push food in quickly.
The biggest benefits for babies
The clearest advantage was family mealtimes. Instead of preparing a separate purée and then eating my own dinner later, I could adapt what was already on the table. A low-salt portion of our meal could become finger food, which was particularly helpful on weeknights when I was managing work, bath time and bedtime.
Both children developed an impressive willingness to touch and explore food. They squashed avocado, examined the texture of steamed carrot and gradually learned to move food around their mouths. My first child became a confident eater early, while my second was slower and more selective, proving that baby-led weaning does not create identical results for every child.
It also encouraged us to eat more mindfully. We became better at including vegetables, soft proteins and family-friendly meals instead of relying on packaged snacks. For practical family ideas and everyday parenting stories, I often browse family life ideas when I need inspiration that fits around a busy schedule.
The benefits for working parents
The convenience was real, but it came from planning rather than from baby-led weaning being effortless. On Sunday evenings, I often washed and chopped vegetables, cooked a batch of meatballs or made mini frittatas. Having suitable food ready in the fridge made the next few lunches much less stressful.
The cost was another pleasant surprise. Babies do not need expensive pouches or specialist subscription boxes to start solids. A pumpkin, a bag of frozen peas, eggs and a loaf of bread could provide several meals. In Australia, where grocery prices can make weekly shopping in Sydney, Melbourne or Brisbane feel painfully expensive, using ordinary supermarket ingredients matters.
There were still days when convenience foods saved us. I kept low-salt options available for outings and tired evenings, checking labels carefully. Food Standards Australia New Zealand rules require packaged foods to declare major allergens, which is useful, although parents still need to read the full ingredient list and consider how a food has been prepared.
For budget-conscious meal planning, I also found ideas through frugal family meals, especially when I needed to stretch leftovers without making dinner feel repetitive.
The mess is bigger than expected
Baby-led weaning creates a spectacular amount of mess. Food landed on the highchair, bib, floor, walls and occasionally the dog. A wipe-clean mat helped, but it did not eliminate the daily sweeping. I learned to keep a damp cloth nearby and to accept that the kitchen would not look tidy after every meal.
Our Australian weather made outdoor eating useful during warmer months. We could take soft fruit and toast onto the balcony or patio, although flies, ants and hot surfaces needed consideration. In cooler Adelaide or Canberra mornings, we stayed indoors and used a washable mat under the chair.
The mess was easier once I stopped treating every meal as a precious developmental activity. Sometimes I gave the baby a few pieces while we ate, cleaned up afterwards and moved on. A useful highchair with a removable tray was more valuable than a collection of clever feeding gadgets.
I also found ways to reuse equipment rather than buy more. This guide to repurposing baby items gave me practical ideas for extending the life of items we had already purchased.
Safety required constant attention
Choking was my biggest fear, and it should be taken seriously. I completed infant first-aid training and learned the difference between gagging and choking before starting. Gagging can be noisy and is part of learning, while choking may be silent and requires immediate action. Babies must sit upright and be supervised closely throughout the meal.
We avoided whole grapes, raw apple, popcorn, nuts, hard chunks of meat, firm sausage pieces and other foods that could block an airway. Grapes were quartered lengthways, apples were cooked or grated, and meat was served very soft and easy to shred. A baby should never eat while crawling, reclining, playing or riding in the car.
Allergen introduction also needed a calm plan. We introduced foods such as smooth peanut butter, well-cooked egg and dairy in safe forms, following Australian allergy advice and discussing concerns with our GP or child health nurse. Once tolerated, we kept them in the family menu regularly rather than offering them once and forgetting about them.
Childcare added another layer. Some Australian centres have detailed policies about nuts, food sharing and allergy management under their own risk procedures. I gave carers clear instructions about textures and allergens, and checked that they were comfortable with the foods being offered.
What I would change the second time
With my first child, I worried about every untouched piece of food. I measured portions in my head and felt anxious when a meal ended mostly on the floor. My second experience was calmer because I understood that milk remained the main source of nutrition during the early months of solids, and early meals were about learning as well as eating.
I offered smaller amounts and added more familiar foods alongside new ones. If my baby was tired, teething or unwell, I did not force the issue. A yoghurt pouch, mashed banana or spoon-fed meal on an unusually difficult day did not cancel the entire approach.
I also stopped comparing babies. My first loved broccoli and ignored banana. My second did the opposite. One ate large amounts quickly, while the other took months to become interested in proper meals. Temperament, appetite, development and family routine all shaped the experience.
That flexibility made room for real life. We could enjoy a café meal, visit grandparents or manage a late workday without turning feeding into a rigid project. The best method was the one that kept everyone safe, fed and reasonably calm.
How it fitted around sleep and family life
Feeding does not exist separately from the rest of parenting. When nights were broken, I had less patience for elaborate meals and less energy for cleaning. Establishing a predictable evening rhythm helped me cope with the demands of food preparation, especially during the transition from one nap to two.
My experience with sleep training our babies also influenced how I thought about mealtimes. Rest did not solve every parenting problem, but better sleep made it easier to prepare food safely, sit down with the children and respond calmly to a messy or frustrating meal.
We also learned to separate hunger from tiredness. A baby who was overtired often grabbed food, cried or threw everything. Offering solids after a nap, when possible, produced much better results. This small timing adjustment made baby-led meals feel far more manageable.
As the children grew, they moved towards ordinary family food with fewer adaptations. The early stage was temporary, and remembering that helped me avoid buying too many specialised products or expecting perfect table manners from a six-month-old.
The verdict after two children
Baby-led weaning worked well for our family, but it was not as effortless as social media sometimes suggests. It reduced the need to prepare separate purées, encouraged shared meals and helped both children become comfortable with different textures. It also created plenty of laundry, food waste and moments of doubt.
The approach suited us best when it was flexible. Finger foods formed the foundation, but spoon-fed yoghurt, mashed meals and supermarket shortcuts had a place too. There was no prize for refusing every pouch or cleaning the floor immediately after every meal.
I would recommend learning choking first aid, following Australian infant-feeding guidance, introducing allergens thoughtfully and choosing foods based on developmental readiness. I would also recommend protecting your energy. A fed, supervised baby and a parent who is coping matter more than following a feeding philosophy perfectly.
If you are beginning solids, start with one safe food, sit with your baby and allow plenty of time for practice. Keep meals simple, share what you can from the family table and let experience—not online perfection—shape your routine.